The Sacramental Versus the Symbolic View of the Lord’s Supper

John 6:49–51
49 Your fathers ate the manna in the wilderness, and they died.
50 This is the bread which comes down out of heaven, so that one may eat of it and not die.
51 I am the living bread that came down out of heaven; if anyone eats of this bread, he will live forever; and the bread also which I will give for the life of the world is My flesh.

V. 49: Jesus continues to distinguish between the physical bread that came as manna from God through Moses in the wilderness and the loaves Jesus used to feed the five thousand, and the living bread from heaven that he offers by believing in him (vv. 32, 33, 41, 42, 50, 51, 58). People could eat the bread from Moses or from Jesus when he fed the five thousand, and they would still die. Jesus is continually trying to move them to think spiritually about the bread one eats and never dies. He gave them bread on the Syrian hillside to fill their stomachs, but like the Jews in the wilderness, they would still die. In contrast, he offers himself as the bread of life (vv. 48, 51). That which Moses and the Israelites had in the wilderness, as well as what Jesus gave in feeding the five thousand, was bread for bios, biological life, if they received it, but Jesus is the bread that, if received, gives zoe,real life eternal.

This bread is the solution for death. By receiving it, you conquer death (v. 50). Jesus was the true bread that came down from heaven, existed in heaven before coming down, and was sent from the Father. Jesus says, “Your fathers” (v. 49), in contrast to his Father (v. 32). The manna in the wilderness and the bread that fed the five thousand were both miracles, but they were also ordinary bread, unlike what Christ is and offers: the bread of eternal life. The manna did not protect them from physical death; they died, but by receiving Christ, the bread of life, they will not die. But like the manna in the wilderness and the bread Jesus gave in the feeding of the five thousand, if they did not choose to receive it, it did them no good, and neither does Jesus, the bread of life, unless they choose to receive him.

V. 51: I do not believe this explains the Lord’s Supper, sacramentalism, which takes place about a year after this, the night before the crucifixion (Matt 26:20–30). The context differentiates between earthly and eternal bread, receiving them to sustain physical and eternal life. If anyone eats of this bread, it parallels eating the manna and the bread Jesus gave in the miracle. The phrase seems to be equivalent to believes (vv. 29, 35, 40, 47, 69), comes to him (v. 35), beholds him (v. 40), listens to learn from him (v. 45), and receives (John 1:12; 5:43). The whole passage contrasts the bread that is eaten for temporary physical sustenance with eating this bread (receiving Christ by faith) and living forever (vv. 40, 47, 50, 54, 58). The statement, the bread also which I will give for the life of the world is my flesh seems to refer to Jesus giving his life on the cross in that he is “the lamb of God that takes away the sins of the world” (John 1:29). He gives his life for the world of humanity and offers the benefits to all who receive it by believing, which all can do (vv. 27, 33, John 1:12; 3:16, 2 Cor 5:18–19; 1 John 2:2).

God’s love (John 3:16) gave Christ, the bread of life, so whoever believes (receives, comes, and eats) will have eternal life. God gave him for the world of humanity, and the world can come to him because God loves his creation. The Son was designated as the gift (John 4:10; 6:32), and now, more specifically, the gift is his flesh (his life), given for all the world. A person must trust that the food is good for him to eat (receive) to benefit physically; to eat Christ means to trust him enough to receive him and his teaching. And once again, we see the clear scope of God’s salvific love: Christ’s payment for sin is for the world of humanity. This is the consistent message of this passage and of John’s gospel as a whole. Limiting it to a theorized group of people is an artificial interpolation from a system of thought rather than from Scripture.

John 6:52–59
52 Then the Jews began to argue with one another, saying, “How can this man give us His flesh to eat?”
53 So Jesus said to them, Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, you have no life in yourselves.
54 He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day.
55 For My flesh is true food, and My blood is true drink.
56 He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood abides in Me, and I in him.
57 As the living Father sent Me, and I live because of the Father, so he who eats Me, he also will live because of Me.
58 This is the bread which came down out of heaven; not as the fathers ate and died; he who eats this bread will live forever.”
59 These things He said in the synagogue as He taught in Capernaum.

V. 52: The Jews are still thinking naturally, as though he is claiming that literally, his flesh is to be eaten as one would eat manna or loaves instead of metaphorically or spiritually receiving him like one had to receive the manna and depend on it. As has been emphasized, one must believe he is the bread from heaven; if a person receives this bread, he gets eternal life. So, rather than believe, they argue as they did earlier (v. 41: grumble), just like their ancestors grumbled with Moses in the wilderness (Exod 16:1–4; 17:2). Humanly, they thought, how can this mere man, a son of Joseph, give them flesh to eat, and how could it have spiritual benefit?

We see similar human responses in the encounters with Nicodemus (John 3:3–9), the Samaritan woman (John 4:1–45), and repeatedly with the Pharisees, who saw only his humanity. He sought to lead them to a deeper understanding of what he was saying, in accordance with Scripture about who he was, but they continued to hear his words through their human understanding, traditions, and experiences, which always led them to reject Christ’s words as ludicrous. This is the result of attempting to come to Christ in their own way and in their own strength (the broad way) while rejecting the Father’s drawing to come by believing his revelation (the narrow way). They seek to come to Christ based on the composite of their human experience, knowledge, understanding, and wisdom, which is seeking salvation on the broad road, a path that only leads to destruction. They, and we, must accept God’s revelation above all human wisdom, experience, and understanding. Knowing Christ means accepting revelation and sifting our human knowledge through it, rather than accepting human knowledge and sifting all revelation through it.

V. 53–54: Although using different terms, this illustration mirrors what Jesus said about coming, believing, and learning. The result is the same for the person who spiritually receives the bread and blood: if he acts in accordance with Jesus’s commands and calls to believe, he has eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day.[1] This is the fourth time Jesus used the phrase Truly, truly I say to you (vv. 26, 32, 47). The phrase Truly, truly (ἀμήν ἀμήν) is from the word we get the word amen,so be it. Jesus uses this “double ἀμήν in John (25 times).”[2] It is a “strong affirmation of what is declared—‘truly, indeed, it is true that.’”[3] In the Old Testament, it was “used also in oaths or imprecations being equivalent to a binding promise (Neh. 5:13; Deut. 27:15–26, in the Sept. rendered génoito).”[4]

Jesus used the phrase “truly truly” to strongly affirm the truthfulness of what he was saying so that, while difficult to hear, they would believe and follow him. It seems Jesus gave these added words of confirmation to help their unbelief. They added strength to his words, and it seems he said this to help them believe. If they truly believed in Jesus, his words, even the hard ones, Jesus would reinforce their weak faith to trust the difficult things he said. This is reminiscent of the truth; if the Jews had truly trusted the words of God and Moses, they would have trusted Christ. It is like the demoniac father who looked beyond his life experience with his son’s life of bondage and no hope in sight until he believed Jesus could help, but he also “cried out and said, ‘I do believe; help my unbelief’” (Mark 9:24).

If they would believe what they did not understand because Jesus said it and they believed in him, they would come to understand that Jesus was speaking of the life in his death, burial, and resurrection, and that life is received by believing (vv. 40, 47, 50–51). They had already heard these teachings, and Borchert remarks, “As such, 6:54 is parallel to the Son of Man saying in 6:40, and the means of gaining life is there identified not as eating and drinking but as seeing and believing. The means to eternal life, accordingly, is not eating and drinking communion elements, but believing is the means of inwardly accepting the suffering death of the Passover Lamb who gave his life for the sin of the world (cf. 1:29; 6:33).”[5]

V. 55–59: True life is in Jesus, not in receiving things that symbolize his life and death, but by receiving him, who is life, by faith. We then symbolize this by baptism and the Lord’s Supper. The Son has life because the Father, who is life, sent him (vv. 56–57), and those who eat (believe, receive, learn, come to him in faith) will have life because Christ is life (John 5:26).

If we choose true food and true drink, he abides in us, and we in him (John 17:4f; 1 John 3:24). He returns to the symbol of eating the bread, and unlike the manna they ate and the bread Jesus provided to the thousands that brought only temporal sustenance, receiving this bread from heaven, which is Jesus (v. 48), brings eternal life. Verse 56 abides in me and I in him clearly indicates Jesus is not speaking literally (of the physical body), even though the food he offers is spiritually real. Then, verse 59 notes that Jesus gave his bread of life teachings in the synagogue when he taught in Capernaum.

The truth is, as Stern points out, “The point is that Jewish understanding allows for symbolic interpretation of ‘food and drink.’ To eat the flesh of the Son of Man is to absorb his entire way of being and living … Yeshua wants us to live, feel, think, and act like him; by the power of Ruach HaKodesh [Holy Spirit, Divine inspiration], he enables us to do so. Likewise, to drink his blood is to absorb his self-sacrificing life-motivation and indeed his very life, since ‘the life of the flesh is in the blood’ (Leviticus 17:11).”[6]

Jesus is saying the same thing, using the physical properties of flesh and blood, as he did before with food and bread, only in different ways and words. Jesus’s analogical speaking of material things (signs, hunger, thirst, physical bread, works, physical life) was to lead them beyond thinking physically to thinking spiritually and eternally (the spiritual meaning of signs, true satisfaction found in everlasting life, the spiritual bread of eternal life, faith, and the heavenly Father and his Son).

Jesus started this analogical teaching in v. 27 when Jesus said, “Do not work for the food which perishes [physical], but for the food which endures to eternal life [spiritual], which the Son of Man will give to you” (John 6:27). His speaking of eating his flesh and drinking his blood was in keeping with his analogical approach in the previous verses of this passage, such as moving them away from physical bread to spiritual bread, himself (6:35, 48, 51). Although he spoke of eating the spiritual bread that comes down from heaven, “This is the bread which comes down out of heaven, so that one may eat of it and not die” (John 6:50), he is plainly using bread to encompass himself and believing in him. He clearly states this several times, such as when he says, “Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes has eternal life” (John 6:47).

The people were thinking humanly (the works they could do v. 27, Jesus’s parents whom they knew v. 42, the physical bread they ate v. 26, normal life v. 27), and he was calling them to walk by faith and believe in the spiritual reality his words represented. The call to eat his flesh and drink his blood was a call to spiritual thinking that transcended the physicality of his words. Eat and drink convey the same meaning as believe and come, as used earlier.

These symbols and his words were like earlier illustrative physicalities; they called listeners to trust him, despite natural realities to the contrary. His call is to believe what they did not fully understand, trusting that if they would so choose, their faith would take them beyond full stomachs, human life and works, and what they could see with their natural eyes, to what they can only see with spiritual eyes of faith and only experience by believing, transcending natural life by passing into eternal spiritual life with God and his Son.

His words are summed up and their spiritual reality definitively demonstrated to be spiritual by his emphasis on the spiritual reality of abiding, “He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood abides in Me, and I in him” (John 6:56). Abiding in Christ and Christ in us is a spiritual reality only brought about by other spiritual realities: believing, coming in faith, and obedience and not by physically eating flesh and blood. Jesus later says, “Abide in Me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself unless it abides in the vine, so neither can you unless you abide in Me” (John 15:4). Notice he uses a literal branch and vine to portray abiding spiritually in him, and an actual fruit to symbolize the spiritual fruit that results, such as righteousness, fruit of the Holy Spirit in Galatians 5:22, godly deeds, faithful works, and conduct. We are to no more literally drink Christ’s blood or eat his flesh than we are to produce bananas and cantaloupes by abiding in Christ. Also, John says, “Whoever confesses that Jesus is the Son of God, God abides in him, and he in God” (1 John 4:15). Confessing and believing are spiritual realities that were portrayed by eating flesh and drinking blood.

Jesus says of himself, “For the bread of God is that which comes down out of heaven, and gives life to the world” (John 6:33). The bread is not physical bread, nor is Jesus calling us to eat his physical flesh as we would physical bread, but rather, spiritually speaking, we are to come and rely on him as man does on physical food in this life; we are to believe and follow his revelation.

Resultantly, we see that Jesus uses blood and bread symbolically, as he had been speaking symbolically and analogically beginning in John 6:27. Also important to remember is that Jesus was physically present when he instituted the Lord’s Supper by transitioning from the Passover. The Seder (meal) includes three pieces of matzah. The three pieces of matzah (bread) were placed in a special holder called a matzah cover. Early in the Seder, the middle matzah is broken, and the smaller piece is placed back in the matzah cover between the other two pockets containing the other two pieces of matzah. The father hides the larger piece, and then (traditionally) at the end of the meal the children try to find the hidden piece; often, the one who finds it is rewarded. Each person eats a bite of the recovered matzah. This is the matzah Jesus used to institute the Lord’s Supper. The Passover had three glasses of wine, and the third one, the last one drunk, is the cup of redemption. That is the one Jesus used to inaugurate the Lord’s Supper.

Although the Jews did not understand it this way, as a Christian, we can easily see the symbolic nature of the matzah. The three-sleeved carrier that holds the bread is symbolic, or analogically related, to the Trinity. The middle matza, symbolic of God the Son, Christ, who was buried and then rose from the dead, and offers himself to all who desire to come to him and depend on him.

In the Seder, the wine and bread, mixed with faith, symbolized the redemptive spiritual reality of the Passover lamb, bringing forth redemption, which the Jews remember in celebration of their deliverance from the bondage of slavery in Egypt. In like manner, in the Lord’s Supper, the wine and bread, mixed with faith, symbolize the spiritual reality of Christ’s sacrifice for the sins of the world, demonstrating that the believer possesses eternal life, which Christians celebrate. “For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until He comes” (1 Corinthians 11:26).

Therefore, the Lord’s Supper, as was the Seder, is symbolic, not literal or sacramental, and the elements neither become the actual body and blood of Christ nor confer sanctifying grace on the believer’s soul.  


[1] They were well aware they could not eat literal flesh or drink blood (Lev 3:17; 17:10–14). As mentioned before, it is not teaching transubstantiation or anything related to the Eucharist since the last Passover and institution of the Lord’s Supper was a year away. Contextually, he is reiterating the same message in a different way but still in keeping with the bread symbol.

[2] Heinz-Wolfgang Kuhn, s.v. “ἀμήν,” in Exegetical Dictionary of the New Testament, 1:70.

[3] Louw and Nida, s.v. “72.6 ἀμήν,” in Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, 1:672.

[4] Zodhiates, s.v. “281. ἀμήν amḗn,” in The Complete Word Study Dictionary: New Testament, 134.

[5] Borchert, John 1–11, 272.

[6] Stern, Jewish New Testament Commentary, 174.

Posted in

Ronnie W. Rogers

Leave a Comment